Since my last blog, a few things have happened, mostly building up to making the documentary about youth and violence that we hope to complete by next week. I’m only here for a week and a half more, so we have to move quickly to get it done, but I’m confident we will.
There was one incident, though, which deserves a blog entry of its own, and I’d like to share it with you, but at the same time let you know that I’m feeling totally fine and there is no need to be concerned about me.
Last Friday, I witnessed a fatal shooting in a supermarket carpark.
There are some areas in South Africa where you can sense the dodginess - there’s something about the way people are dressed, about the loitering young men, the rubbish around the place, and general disorder. Such areas are the kind of places I’ve learned to spot since being mugged in one back on Christmas Eve, and the places that I stay clear of generally when I can help it.
Melmoth is a small town where the organisation I am working with bases its community office. It’s not the kind of place a tourist would come to - there’s not much there to see, and a lot of the town has that dodgy feel to it. The supermarket has that feel, and with my fellow interns we joked about its seediness and the fact that we felt our car would be broken into, or that we would be mugged.
On Friday afternoon, after work, Jenny, the manager of JAW, and I were at the supermarket, and just about to drive out of the carpark when we heard a single gunshot. I wouldn’t have realised it was a gunshot if it weren’t for the scattering, panicking crowd, and for the black man who fell to the ground in the carpark driveway.
I couldn’t believe what I was seeing; it was exactly like a scene in a movie. We all know what a murder looks like from seeing them over and over on TV, but no one ever thinks they will see it happen in real life. We didn’t see the killer, and he must have disappeared fairly quickly, as most of the people around didn’t take long before they went to take a closer look at the victim.
Before the crowd formed, I saw the man’s face, as he writhed in pain. I didn’t see his wound- just the look on his face. A woman came up beside him and started crying uncontrollably - the look on her face was unforgettable. It reminded me of a
photo I’ve seen of when a schoolboy called Hector Pieterson was shot in Soweto in the 1970s during apartheid - his sister‘s face is almost hauntingly similar. Words can’t describe the grief and sorrow on her face - a loved one whose life has been taken away in a flash. I didn’t know any more about the victim, the woman or the killer. But they were all human.
I only worried about my own life for a split second - perhaps it was because there was only one gunshot, and perhaps because the crowd formed quite soon, which suggested the locals were confident the gunman was both gone and not after anyone except the one he had hit. I was worried about my general safety though, and stayed in the car while Jenny called the police. I didn’t think of doing so - I guess nothing like that crossed my mind, except for shock to see that a man had been shot down in front of me.
The formation of the huge, equally shocked crowd proved that while South Africa is violent, it’s not so violent that people have become completely desensitised to murder. People are still human enough to see the loss of life as a big thing, even a country with one of the highest homicide rates in the world. At the same time, there are some people whose lack of love or moral sense disgusts me - a minibus taxi driver viciously honked at the crowd to get out of his way, so that he could exit the carpark. It didn’t seem to matter to him, or another driver who followed, nearly hitting a woman on the way out, that a man had just been shot dead - there were simply more important things going on in their lives.
Jenny got out of the car to see if there was any way she could help. Helping the man was the last thing on my mind - perhaps because of my fear that I would be next if I got too close, and also because in a moment of shock and fear, I think such feelings slip away unless you are somewhat prepared. That’s perhaps why most people stood around doing nothing, rather than calling the police or seeing what they could do to help. We’re simply not built to respond to that kind of thing, and I don’t blame people for standing by doing nothing, or running away. Jenny returned to the car quickly, resigned. She didn’t have to even say the words - the look on her face told me the poor man was dead.
We left the scene, as the crowd grew bigger and the police arrived. As we drove back to our B&B I was in shock, and couldn’t say a word for quite some time. It took me a few hours just to think it over, but I was surprised when I was able to engage in normal conversation by dinner time.
I’m surprised, a few days on, looking back and saying that while seeing the shooting was one of the most shocking moments of my life, I think I’ve dealt with it quite well. I haven’t broken down about it or exhibited any of the symptoms the psychologist told me were common as a result of trauma. I’m aware that something might come later on, and that these things can be triggered by something. Both Monash and Oxfam have been quick to support me and offer counselling and even an early flight home. I declined the earlier flight. I didn’t think I needed the counselling, but Oxfam booked it for me as something they do for any volunteer who witnesses something like that. And I think it was good, because it enabled me to explore how I have responded to the incident, and it’s prepared me for what may come later on.
The psychologist said I had done pretty well in coping with it, perhaps due to the way I think things through and also because I see myself as detached from the kind of environment where it happened. If it happened at home, it might have been a totally different story, but the fact that I already saw this supermarket carpark as a dodgy area perhaps mentally prepared me to be able to deal with things that may have happened. It’s also perhaps the fact that I’ve been mugged at knifepoint in this country and that I’ve read and heard so much about crime here, that have prepared me for such an incident. I don’t think anything can prepare you for the shock of seeing a man get shot about 15-20m from you, but I think my reaction would have been more emotional if it had happened in an area where I feel safe, like back home.
I’m going back to Melmoth tomorrow. I don’t feel scared about it, or any more scared than I do about going anywhere in this country. When I walk in the streets now, I am wary about being mugged, as I’ve always been, but I don’t fear that I’ll see another shooting. To me I see it as an isolated incident - there was surely a background to the shooting which I don’t know or understand - perhaps linked into some bigger crime. The supermarket wasn’t one of the areas that white people and foreigners should never go to - sure it was dodgier than some areas, but not so dodgy that people should avoid it. I think it was more a case of an incident that could have happened anywhere happening there, and in front of me.
Maybe something will trigger me in a month’s time when I’m back home, and I’ll get flashbacks. But I don’t think it will, and neither did my psychologist, not because I’m strong, or that I’m too macho to cry or to get shaken up, but maybe just because of the way my thought processes work and the way I rationalise things. I hardly thought about the shooting over the weekend or afterwards, except when people asked me about it. I haven’t played any violent computer games since it happened, and I don’t know if something might happen to me when I do. But I don’t think so.
I also have to admit that the victim and the poor girl haven’t crossed my mind much since Friday. Maybe because of my detachment from the situation. I think that if I had had any emotional connections to them it would be a completely different story. But it was like I just got a little window into a distant, foreign world that I don’t understand and never will, and saw into the lives of people I will never know, just for the brief moment where I saw the agony on the man’s face and the distress on the woman’s. I don’t even know if she was his sister, or his partner, or friend. I just know that to feel pain like what she felt would arguably be as awful as being the one who was shot.
Please don’t worry about me - I have had a good session with a psychologist and we are both confident that I am doing fine.